My thoughts on the Stop Online Piracy Act
As a musician, I accept the fact that only about half of the folks who listen to our music have actually paid for it. That's the cost of doing business on the internet. I counter it as best I can by using equal portions of vigilance and guilt, and LPN has netted a pretty penny in album sales over the years. At the same time I realize that we're just chump change. The problems of a rinky-dink
unsigned swing band don't amount to a hill of beans in the big time entertainment industry. The executives in charge want EVERY PENNY of what's coming to them, regardless of the fact that digital sales probably offset the cost of theft by cutting production costs nearly in half (why print a CD when you can sell a computer file, which doesn't even exist physically?).
This is nothing new, unfortunately. Frank Zappa spent the eighties fighting the Blank Tape Tax (amongst other ridiculous attempted music legislation). Hey media bigwigs: this shit IS going to happen. Users are going to share files, just like people are going to play DVDs for their friends and football games will be shown in bars. And now that I think of it, how is file-sharing any different than ride-sharing? Should I pay Chrysler a fee every time I have passengers in my car?
Oh, one last thing. I try to be a responsible user. I buy legally whenever feasible, and I resort to bittorrents only when the desired files are either difficult to find or ludicrously expensive (or enormously successful, in which case they won't miss my $12). See? Vigilance and guilt! SOPA is, to use
Zappa's words,
"an ill-conceived piece of nonsense which... promises to keep the courts busy for years dealing with the interpretational and enforcemental problems inherent in the proposal's design."The web is world-wide. It's a world wide web, that's what those three W's stand for. Who the fuck are WE to think that we can impose our legislation on the rest of the world?